Home - The Musical Box Mail Hal C F Astell - Site Map

Probot II, Mr Grohl?

While I'm no devoted fan, I'm happy to claim that I enjoy a lot of Nirvana. I'd even say that I enjoy a little Foo Fighters now and then but they're far less vital to me. But in 2003, Dave Grohl, drummer for both bands, released an album that is going to have a long shelflife with me and he called the project Probot.

One of the things that made Nirvana so great was the varied influences that each member brought to the band. It's well known in certain circles that Kurt Cobain was a huge Jandek fan, for instance, and Grohl was an underground metal fan of long standing. It's these influences that Grohl explores with Probot. He plays almost all the instruments on the album (with some help from Kim Thayil of Soundgarden), but he doesn't sing at all. Instead he invited a wide range of metal idols to write the lyrics and perform the vocal duties over his backing music.

And what names! Here's the track listing including the guest vocalists:

Track Vocalist Band(s)
Centuries of Sin Cronos Venom
Red War Max Cavalera Sepultura
Shake Your Blood Lemmy Motörhead
Access Babylon Mike Dean Corrosion of Conformity
Silent Spring Kurt Brecht DRI
Ice Cold Man Lee Dorrian Cathedral
The Emerald Law Wino Saint Vitus, The Obsessed
Big Sky Tom G Warrior Celtic Frost
Dictatosaurus Snake Voivod
My Tortured Soul Eric Wagner Trouble
Sweet Dreams King Diamond Mercyful Fate

There's also a hidden track sung by actor Jack Black who performs as Tenacious D, but that's hardly important in the scheme of things. Most of the songs are killers, with few down points. Sadly, given his consistent output over a few decades, it's Lemmy's track that is the least of the bunch, but I have to admit that even that's grown on me somewhat since my first dozen times through.

Apparently other names were involved at points. Chuck Schuldiner of Death was approached as a potential name but he was fighting brain cancer and died before he could take part. The obvious game here (at least for me) is to come up with other names who weren't involved but could always be included on a sequel. Given the trouble that Grohl had to go through to get the Probot album released and the fact that it didn't rack up huge sales, it's unfortunately unlikely that a second volume could be made. However if it did, who would be on it?

Here at least are some of my suggestions, ignoring such obvious names as Halford, Dio or Gillan, and I'd love to hear any of the following baker's dozen of vocalists perform on Probot II. They were all major names in the metal underground with very recognisably distinct voices and they represent a similar cross section of the genre to that demonstrated in the first Probot. I'd also be interested to see what Dave Grohl would have to say about them.

Vocalist Band(s)
Blaine The Accüsed
Glenn Danzig The Misfits
Ann Boleyn Hellion
Udo Dirkschneider Accept, Udo
Schmier Destruction
Midnight Crimson Glory
Messiah Marcolin Candlemass
HR Bad Brains
Billy Milano SOD, MOD
Chuck Billy Testament
Martin Walkyier Sabbat, Skyclad
John Cyriis Agent Steel

Inevitably there are other now deceased names who couldn't possibly be involved, such as Paul Baloff (Exodus) and Wendy O Williams (The Plasmatics) but I enjoy imagining their potential contributions too. Since I wrote this piece, Quorthon of Bathary has also died.

So, what about it? Probot II, Mr Grohl?

Home - The Musical Box Mail Hal C F Astell - Site Map